HC - Muslims not minorities in UP: TN Andhra for Religious Quota
Tags: Allhabad High Court Muslim Non-Minority UP Vote bank Ministry Flight from freedom Seculrism in danger Quota Reservation Rahul roadshow UPA Dalit Christian Voter ID Hinduism SC CM;
Vote bankers are bankrupts; new graves have no space; Even Quotas on driver seat and on bus top; Minority train with full speed without break and destination
In fact in India there is no minority, all are Indians. Did India get freedom to act for the “flight from freedom” Do we Indians really want freedom with all the responsibility that goes with.
"Man is born free; and everywhere he is in chains," Rousseau
How would you define what a national minority is?
What criteria would you assign to define minority groups? For example: should minority groups be defined by a certain percentage of the national population? If so, what should that percentage be? Should the definition of a minority group be related to how long that group has lived in its country? Should the definition be tied strictly to ethnicity and culture?
The word "minority" has not been defined in the Constitution. The Motilal Nehru Report, 1928, showed a prominent desire to afford protection to minorities, but did not define the _expression. The Sapru Report, 1945, also proposed, inter alia, a Minorities Commission, which exists today, but did not define minority. It is beleived that the UN too has not said anything on 'who constitutes a minority. No definition of minority is in our Constitution also. We are making fool to sit on non exist not defined train of secularism and minoritysim.
It is beleived that the UN too has not said anything on 'who constitutes a minority.' There is an absolute necessity to define ' Who can be called a Minority' whether this be based on a percentage of the total population in the country or whether it be on religious or caste basis. Then we would have another problem crop up in the states of Punjab, where Sikhs are in a majority, in J & K, where Muslims are in a majority and in parts of the North East where Christians are in a majority. Then with the growing conversions of Hindus to Christianity and Muslim a few States could find themselves in a quandary. Budhism, Sikhism and Jainism are the branch of Hinduism.Then we have to look at the large number of castes. When figures are taken into consideration, then SCs/STs including Dalits would constitute percentages well over the limited percentage. We find that the government, in a craze for votes, attaches moresignificance to Muslims and Christians, even at the cost of the Dalit Hindus. And all this is very dangerous in the years ahead. But if the government and Political parties are sincere and faithful to the Constitution of India, they would
In fact call and need of the time is that we should ensure that Liberty, Equality, Justice & Fraternity are strictly adhered to; all kinds of 'doling out' should be purely on economic basis as there are more numbers from the majority community who are 'hand to mouth'.
Fake secularism in danger
So called secularists’ dreams become the dreams of ‘Mungerilal’ in UP Assembly election after coming the judgement of Allahabad High Court that Muskims in UP are now not in minority. Secular devil forces want voters for few hours every five years. Caste religion based Reservation is secularism. Divide and rule-British policy is Congress vote bank politics in independent India. In the name of secularism every sin is done. These caste and religious based secularism is played to abolish the caste and religious discrimination. Rahul read statement to say that since last 15 years UP is divided by caste and religion basis. People should know how, yesterday’s boy dare to fool voters.
Minority Status in India is actually a curse for the common people in India. The beneficiaries of this status are some people who claim that they are the leaders of the minorities.
Muslims not minorities in UP: Allahabad HCIn a landmark judgement, the allhabad High Court on April 5, 2007 said the UP government should treat members of the Muslim community as equal to those belonging to the non-minority communities without discrimination in accordance with law. The court also asked the UP government to treat all Muslim institutions applying for grant-in-aid at par with non-minority institutions without any discrimination.
Justice Srivastava also issued a notice to the Centre and the UP government to take appropriate steps to modify an October 23, 1993 notification issued by the Central government on the grant of minority status.
The issue is likely to increase the polarisation of pro- and anti-minority votes.
The first impact of the judgement will most likely be felt on Saturday, when UP goes to polls in the first phase, specially in places like Agra which have high Muslim concentration. The campaigning for the first phase of polls ends today.
Minority front
Are massiah of minority front are Gandhis, Arjun, VP, Ram Vilas, Mulayam, Lalu, Andhra CM, YS Rajasekhara Reddy, Karunanidhi and others belongs to minority community? Minority Company or other entity that is ostensibly owned by a minority, but in fact, owned financed, or controlled by a non-minority person or entity. Such fronts are established to qualify for preferential treatment in the awarding of government contracts
Minority train with full speed without break and destination
France broke the world speed record on rails by creating the world’s fastest train to Attempt 334.8 MPH but in India vote bank politicians broke the record of that France rail. It is running on so called secular track without break without destintion.
Even bus driver seat occupied by the quotas
I recall a comedy: Demand of quota seat is so great that conductor opened the door and even driver seat is occupied by the quotas. Driver drives in standing position. Even passengers travel to climb on the top of the bus and to joom on the entrance gates. Even they breaks the window near to driver seat. Counting of quota and without quota is impossible. So, all get benefit of doubt.
New graves are not finding space
Reuter reported that Christian’s new graves are not finding space in Kolkatta. It is also perhaps the indicators of decrease in the population of Christians! But Sachchar Committee has not said a single word for family planning or keeping more wives. Is in India sufficient space for the graves of Muslims? Population of female is decreasing but Mulims allowed keeping so many wifes. No need to control population.
UPA trying to make Hindus minority
Why Ram Krishna Mission turned itself as non-Hindu? Why Jain wants to be minority? Why there is a competition to be backward instead of forward? Why the Union Minister, without portfolio A.R. Antulay is in the search of provinces where Hindus are in minority? Is this sign of democracy, secularism and progress?
This statistic suggested that while the growth rate for Hindus has fallen between 1991 and 2001 compared with 1981 and 1991, Muslims and Christians have actually grown faster in the last decade, this led Indian media and different parties raising an alarm on this trend.
Rahul roadshow start with Babri to insult Narsimha Rao
Some of the mist over Prime Minister Manmohan Singh's promise of "fair share" for minorities in government jobs could be lifting. Congress on Nov 13 took ownership of proposals for quota benefits for Dalit Muslims and Christians aired by two senior Congress leaders A R Antulay and Veerappa Moily. Even Rahul Gandhi statted his roadshows by giving visit to Deoband as his father Rajiv wanted votes to dishonor SC on Shahbano Case and after that wanted votes of Hindus to statt campaign from Ayodhya
Why Minority Ministry?
Antulay, who is minister for minority affairs, and Moily, chairman of Administrative Reforms Commission, have spoken in favour of reservations for Muslims. Antulay advocated inclusion of Dalit Muslims in the SC/ST quota frame. Yesterday by Andhra government and to day Karunanidhi of TN declared reservation for so called dalit Muslims and Christians.
For the fulfillment of wonders of secularism Congress created Minority Commission and extended caste based reservation policy. Antuley was forced to resign as a CM of Maharshtra due to the corruption. Now he is a cabinet minister for making Hindus in the minority. For this he has made grounds for separating Jains and others from Hunduism. Being a minister he is supporting religious reservation for Muslims.
Voters IDs for militants as for Bangladeshi Infiltreators!
Timesnow reported to day: Lashkar militants, in alleged connivance with bureaucrats, have reportedly managed to acquire Voter identity cards, virtually becoming de-facto citizens of India. Two of these cards were seized from Pakistan-based Lashkar-e-Toiba militants Abdul Majeed and Mohammad Jameel who were arrested from the Jammu and Kashmir's Rajouri district.
What is worse, while scanning electoral records during the course of investigation, police found that 62 other voter ID cards are still missing and no official records were found?
“It causes a lot of concern for people who deal with security, because these cards going in the hands of terrorists can be used anywhere to gain access. And security agencies take it very seriously. I think the officer who is concerned with the safe custody of these cards should be proceeded against under law,’ said Jammu Inspector General Sheeshpal Vaid.
It is open fact that Congress and Communists not only encourage infiltration from Bangladesh but also help them for getting ration cards and enrolling their names in the voterlists. Actually terrorists, insurgents as Maoist and ULFA, separatists and so called minority are the solid voters for them.
"Exclusive" reservation for Muslims, Christians
Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M Karunanidhi announced in the State Assembly today that the state government has decided to create a religion based quota in government jobs and seats in educational institutions of the state.
Interestingly, a similar law passed by the Andhra government, providing 5% reservation to Muslims, was struck down by the state HC last year as unconstitutional. It had then said that reservation based on religion was against Article 15 of the Constitution. The case is now pending, but there seems to be little chance of the AP government getting a favourable verdict.
Advantages over Hindus
Congress and Left in India appease the minority groups, which are their vote banks.
The educational institutions established by non-Hindus can apply for the "Religious Minority Status". This means that 50% of the seats in these institutions are reserved for students belonging to a particular religion. For example, in DBIT Mumbai, 50% of the seats are reserved for Roman Catholic students.
The Aligarh Muslim University (AMU) also enjoyed a minority status (50% of the seats reserved for Muslims), until the High Court declared that the status was anti-constitutional. But the Teachers' and Students' Union of AMU, as well as many political leaders protested this decision of the Court.
Many Muslims groups have also asked for quotas in prestigious institutions managed by Government. A committee set up by the HRD minister Arjun Singh in 2005 recommended quotas for Muslims in institutions such as IITs, IIMs and IIFT.
There is a special concession given to Muslims for pilgrimages (Hajj). Sri Sri Ravishankar pointed out in a recent interview, in the state of Karnataka alone; the Government takes Rs 40 crores from the temples, while only 50 lakhs are returned to them. On the other hand, mosques generate about 40 lakhs but receive 8 crores from the Government.
By Premendra Agrawal
www.newsanalysisindia.com/
Vote bankers are bankrupts; new graves have no space; Even Quotas on driver seat and on bus top; Minority train with full speed without break and destination
In fact in India there is no minority, all are Indians. Did India get freedom to act for the “flight from freedom” Do we Indians really want freedom with all the responsibility that goes with.
"Man is born free; and everywhere he is in chains," Rousseau
How would you define what a national minority is?
What criteria would you assign to define minority groups? For example: should minority groups be defined by a certain percentage of the national population? If so, what should that percentage be? Should the definition of a minority group be related to how long that group has lived in its country? Should the definition be tied strictly to ethnicity and culture?
The word "minority" has not been defined in the Constitution. The Motilal Nehru Report, 1928, showed a prominent desire to afford protection to minorities, but did not define the _expression. The Sapru Report, 1945, also proposed, inter alia, a Minorities Commission, which exists today, but did not define minority. It is beleived that the UN too has not said anything on 'who constitutes a minority. No definition of minority is in our Constitution also. We are making fool to sit on non exist not defined train of secularism and minoritysim.
It is beleived that the UN too has not said anything on 'who constitutes a minority.' There is an absolute necessity to define ' Who can be called a Minority' whether this be based on a percentage of the total population in the country or whether it be on religious or caste basis. Then we would have another problem crop up in the states of Punjab, where Sikhs are in a majority, in J & K, where Muslims are in a majority and in parts of the North East where Christians are in a majority. Then with the growing conversions of Hindus to Christianity and Muslim a few States could find themselves in a quandary. Budhism, Sikhism and Jainism are the branch of Hinduism.Then we have to look at the large number of castes. When figures are taken into consideration, then SCs/STs including Dalits would constitute percentages well over the limited percentage. We find that the government, in a craze for votes, attaches moresignificance to Muslims and Christians, even at the cost of the Dalit Hindus. And all this is very dangerous in the years ahead. But if the government and Political parties are sincere and faithful to the Constitution of India, they would
In fact call and need of the time is that we should ensure that Liberty, Equality, Justice & Fraternity are strictly adhered to; all kinds of 'doling out' should be purely on economic basis as there are more numbers from the majority community who are 'hand to mouth'.
Fake secularism in danger
So called secularists’ dreams become the dreams of ‘Mungerilal’ in UP Assembly election after coming the judgement of Allahabad High Court that Muskims in UP are now not in minority. Secular devil forces want voters for few hours every five years. Caste religion based Reservation is secularism. Divide and rule-British policy is Congress vote bank politics in independent India. In the name of secularism every sin is done. These caste and religious based secularism is played to abolish the caste and religious discrimination. Rahul read statement to say that since last 15 years UP is divided by caste and religion basis. People should know how, yesterday’s boy dare to fool voters.
Minority Status in India is actually a curse for the common people in India. The beneficiaries of this status are some people who claim that they are the leaders of the minorities.
Muslims not minorities in UP: Allahabad HCIn a landmark judgement, the allhabad High Court on April 5, 2007 said the UP government should treat members of the Muslim community as equal to those belonging to the non-minority communities without discrimination in accordance with law. The court also asked the UP government to treat all Muslim institutions applying for grant-in-aid at par with non-minority institutions without any discrimination.
Justice Srivastava also issued a notice to the Centre and the UP government to take appropriate steps to modify an October 23, 1993 notification issued by the Central government on the grant of minority status.
The issue is likely to increase the polarisation of pro- and anti-minority votes.
The first impact of the judgement will most likely be felt on Saturday, when UP goes to polls in the first phase, specially in places like Agra which have high Muslim concentration. The campaigning for the first phase of polls ends today.
Minority front
Are massiah of minority front are Gandhis, Arjun, VP, Ram Vilas, Mulayam, Lalu, Andhra CM, YS Rajasekhara Reddy, Karunanidhi and others belongs to minority community? Minority Company or other entity that is ostensibly owned by a minority, but in fact, owned financed, or controlled by a non-minority person or entity. Such fronts are established to qualify for preferential treatment in the awarding of government contracts
Minority train with full speed without break and destination
France broke the world speed record on rails by creating the world’s fastest train to Attempt 334.8 MPH but in India vote bank politicians broke the record of that France rail. It is running on so called secular track without break without destintion.
Even bus driver seat occupied by the quotas
I recall a comedy: Demand of quota seat is so great that conductor opened the door and even driver seat is occupied by the quotas. Driver drives in standing position. Even passengers travel to climb on the top of the bus and to joom on the entrance gates. Even they breaks the window near to driver seat. Counting of quota and without quota is impossible. So, all get benefit of doubt.
New graves are not finding space
Reuter reported that Christian’s new graves are not finding space in Kolkatta. It is also perhaps the indicators of decrease in the population of Christians! But Sachchar Committee has not said a single word for family planning or keeping more wives. Is in India sufficient space for the graves of Muslims? Population of female is decreasing but Mulims allowed keeping so many wifes. No need to control population.
UPA trying to make Hindus minority
Why Ram Krishna Mission turned itself as non-Hindu? Why Jain wants to be minority? Why there is a competition to be backward instead of forward? Why the Union Minister, without portfolio A.R. Antulay is in the search of provinces where Hindus are in minority? Is this sign of democracy, secularism and progress?
This statistic suggested that while the growth rate for Hindus has fallen between 1991 and 2001 compared with 1981 and 1991, Muslims and Christians have actually grown faster in the last decade, this led Indian media and different parties raising an alarm on this trend.
Rahul roadshow start with Babri to insult Narsimha Rao
Some of the mist over Prime Minister Manmohan Singh's promise of "fair share" for minorities in government jobs could be lifting. Congress on Nov 13 took ownership of proposals for quota benefits for Dalit Muslims and Christians aired by two senior Congress leaders A R Antulay and Veerappa Moily. Even Rahul Gandhi statted his roadshows by giving visit to Deoband as his father Rajiv wanted votes to dishonor SC on Shahbano Case and after that wanted votes of Hindus to statt campaign from Ayodhya
Why Minority Ministry?
Antulay, who is minister for minority affairs, and Moily, chairman of Administrative Reforms Commission, have spoken in favour of reservations for Muslims. Antulay advocated inclusion of Dalit Muslims in the SC/ST quota frame. Yesterday by Andhra government and to day Karunanidhi of TN declared reservation for so called dalit Muslims and Christians.
For the fulfillment of wonders of secularism Congress created Minority Commission and extended caste based reservation policy. Antuley was forced to resign as a CM of Maharshtra due to the corruption. Now he is a cabinet minister for making Hindus in the minority. For this he has made grounds for separating Jains and others from Hunduism. Being a minister he is supporting religious reservation for Muslims.
Voters IDs for militants as for Bangladeshi Infiltreators!
Timesnow reported to day: Lashkar militants, in alleged connivance with bureaucrats, have reportedly managed to acquire Voter identity cards, virtually becoming de-facto citizens of India. Two of these cards were seized from Pakistan-based Lashkar-e-Toiba militants Abdul Majeed and Mohammad Jameel who were arrested from the Jammu and Kashmir's Rajouri district.
What is worse, while scanning electoral records during the course of investigation, police found that 62 other voter ID cards are still missing and no official records were found?
“It causes a lot of concern for people who deal with security, because these cards going in the hands of terrorists can be used anywhere to gain access. And security agencies take it very seriously. I think the officer who is concerned with the safe custody of these cards should be proceeded against under law,’ said Jammu Inspector General Sheeshpal Vaid.
It is open fact that Congress and Communists not only encourage infiltration from Bangladesh but also help them for getting ration cards and enrolling their names in the voterlists. Actually terrorists, insurgents as Maoist and ULFA, separatists and so called minority are the solid voters for them.
"Exclusive" reservation for Muslims, Christians
Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M Karunanidhi announced in the State Assembly today that the state government has decided to create a religion based quota in government jobs and seats in educational institutions of the state.
Interestingly, a similar law passed by the Andhra government, providing 5% reservation to Muslims, was struck down by the state HC last year as unconstitutional. It had then said that reservation based on religion was against Article 15 of the Constitution. The case is now pending, but there seems to be little chance of the AP government getting a favourable verdict.
Advantages over Hindus
Congress and Left in India appease the minority groups, which are their vote banks.
The educational institutions established by non-Hindus can apply for the "Religious Minority Status". This means that 50% of the seats in these institutions are reserved for students belonging to a particular religion. For example, in DBIT Mumbai, 50% of the seats are reserved for Roman Catholic students.
The Aligarh Muslim University (AMU) also enjoyed a minority status (50% of the seats reserved for Muslims), until the High Court declared that the status was anti-constitutional. But the Teachers' and Students' Union of AMU, as well as many political leaders protested this decision of the Court.
Many Muslims groups have also asked for quotas in prestigious institutions managed by Government. A committee set up by the HRD minister Arjun Singh in 2005 recommended quotas for Muslims in institutions such as IITs, IIMs and IIFT.
There is a special concession given to Muslims for pilgrimages (Hajj). Sri Sri Ravishankar pointed out in a recent interview, in the state of Karnataka alone; the Government takes Rs 40 crores from the temples, while only 50 lakhs are returned to them. On the other hand, mosques generate about 40 lakhs but receive 8 crores from the Government.
By Premendra Agrawal
www.newsanalysisindia.com/
posted by Premendra Agrawal, India at 3:07 AM
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home